posted Tue, 03/28/2023 - 01:28
5207
+ 3 Mike Mentzer opinions?
ad
Someone recently put me onto Mike Mentzer. His theory is interesting and goes mentally against everything we have previously learned. Maybe some of you are doing some type of Mentzer discipline. Dorian Yates swore by this guy. Watch his you tube. Also look up Joe Rohan’s Dorian Yates interview. It’s excellent. I’m probably telling you guys something you already know but just in case you don’t hear it is.
- Bookmark
- 3
- 0
I think people have got this training style all misunderstood. It is not just a little warm up and one set to absolute failure and done. it was warm up sets and working up to that one fucking insane set, kind of what I feel alot of people do its just that Dorian didnt count those sets whereas other guys still count the ones that weren't just a warm up. So lets say lateral raises you warm up with ten pounds then maybe 2 sets with 30 pounds and one hardcore set with 40. Youd probably count that as 3 sets and a warmup. and Dorian might do a set with ten, a set with 20, a set with 30, and a fucking delt assault with 40s but he'll only count that as one. These numbers are all made up as an example and assuming your equally strong as Dorian. This is just how I think someone could possibly grow with "one set". I might be wrong but ive seen someone else explain it in a similar fashion, saying basically his training wasn't so different (besides intensity) then alot of guys, it was just his counting was different. Another thing is I believe he did this training style later on in his career, so it wasn't necessarily how he built his massive foundation. Regardless hes still a fucking animal and I love his training partner in "blood and guts" that guy deserves an award for best training partner/hype man lol.
I trained in Dorians gym when I was in my early twenties. Numerous times I saw him training in this “one working set and done” methodology. You’ve got to understand the intensity though. I’d be 20/21 at the time, and for a bodybuilder his training was comparatively so heavy. His one set of lateral raises would be with a pair of 40kg dumbbells as an example. Very inspiring, but not something most of us mere mortals could do.
I saw that in one of he's videos, lateral raises with that weight, my shoulder pains only by seeing him!
Strong guy. Nice bloke too. Was a total machine tge way he trained.
Yes sir saw him bench 200kg incline with perfect form.. Guy was an animal
There was another guy, Dante Trudell, aka "DoggCrap" who endorsed heavy weight/low volume.
He was probably influenced by Mentzer/Jones. He also took from John Parillo as far as extreme stretching and eating a lot.
There used to be a forum owned by "Animal" who sold "Animal Kits" to convert cattle implants.
So Dante started a thread called "cycle for pennies a day" discussing this conversion process. In the end he started talking more about diet and training and thus the world was exposed to "DC Training. The thread was massive and legendary. Here is a synopsis by Dante:
http://doggcrapp.blogspot.com/2006/11/cycle-for-pennies-condensed.html?m=1
Even though some of his ideas have evolved from what he presented here, you may find it interesting. I'm sure there is stuff on YT as well
Man once again you come with a good post man lol! I've used some of his principles, so I'll try to remember a few things about Ole Mike Mentzer. And yes he was somewhat of a mad scientist, no dummy at all. So this Heavy Duty or HIT training principle that he used with good results originally came from the great Arthur Jones, who invented the Nautilus training equipment. Now along with Mike this dude too was also a bit of a genius. Arnold himself didn't like this system and made fun of it but when he was invited to train with Arthur Jones on Nautilus equipment using HIT principles, Arnold actually quit lol. Short of the long is ole Arnie's mouth was writing checks that his ass couldn't cash lol. Anyways I thought that was interesting. So Mentzer tweaked the idea from Arthur Jones and Dorian Yates tweaked idea from Mentzer. I'd say in all cases it worked for them. Mentzer should of won the 1980 Mr. Olympia most would agree but politics gave it to Arnold and Mentzer held a grudge a long time against Arnold for this. Unfortunately Mike Mentzer died at 49 and his brother Ray died 2 days later or even sooner if I remember right. I believe Mike had heart issues. I understand he experimented alot on himself and took risks but still a sad loss for the bodybuilding community but all should heed the warning.
Yeah I was actually just watching a reel on IG and it was saying how Dorian Yates would just do 1 set of each exercise to failure with a decent amount of weight. And when they say failure they mean forced reps. I've never tried it, but after hearing this I may give it a try. just concerned about injury when using heavier weight loads.
Good point. Yea the biggest issue with this training method is the injury factor and I'm sure Dorian would agree...dude detached his bicep and tricep along with other injuries. Gotta admit he had one of the nastiest physiques ever though. More hard work than genetics I would say. Like someone said though this style worked for him, just like Arnold's style worked for him or Ronnie's style worked for him.
I understand what works for one may not work the same for another but I do believe the fundamental foundation is the same for everyone in a sense but we tweak it for what we feel is best for us. All bread needs yeast hahaha.
Haha I like that...all bread needs yeast. UNLESS it's unleaven bread lol but I get your point.
Yeah but look at the damage that did to Ronnie. he can barely walk now.
It’s sad to see Ronnie living like that. Is that from the gear or the heavy weights?
In my opinion the heavy lifting and he'd say so too. The thing is he doesn't feel sorry for himself and doesn't want anyone else to feel sorry for him. But yeah still sad I know.
For sure. Lol without saying too much I've seen Ronnie a number of times. And let me tell ya, he definitely paid the ultimate price for all that heavy ass lifting. This is the thing though..if you asked him was it really worth it, he'll tell you yes and he'd do it all over again...to me that's unbelievable. Dude has more metal screws in him than a wooden tree house.
No doubt and he continues to train even though he's been advised by his physicians to stop.
I'll just say this too. I've never seen a woman that was his mom's age who looked like she did. She had guns and was ripped lol. Man I'm telling you I can absolutely see where his muscle building genes came from. Ronnie has great genetics combined with a great work ethic. That combination hardly ever fails. Ronnie has always said that Flex Wheeler had even better genetics than he did but he said he just out worked Flex. Goes to show you how far genetics only will take you, Flex was the ultimate example of that.
Thanks Dee! Much appreciated. I never heard the Arnold opinions on Mentzer. I wouldn’t say I’m filling the Mentzer method but I’m incorporating some of his principles and see what happens.
No problem man. Damn I wish I trained with all those " Ole school" 70's guys, the hell with the new! Ole Mike Mentzer was thick and it was known that he didn't eat alot. I have that same appetite issue myself. Anyways good luck and test it out.
It was definitely a different world for the pioneers. We are so lucky we had those amazing guys. So sad that so many left us so early
Mike Mentzer was a bit if a genius in a sense. I train in a Dorian Yates type fashion for many years and yes it works gives you hard dense muscle. But they're are more than one way to stimulate muscle growth as I got older and injuries will happen I can train different now that I built a physique I don't need to kill myself anymore. I do still train hard and to failure but not with the same poundage. It's not needed
Hope all is well with ya. I'll give you a shout out later on my pic post. Anyways I know you like Dorian so I have a lil info in above comment. That method was definitely perfected by Dorian no doubt with his nasty, rugged, dense and grainy physique.
Dorian was the best
Lifted-presence92Dude was a different breed it’s like Ronnie and jay the way they trained worked for them and won’t work for others that degree true freaks of bodybuilding.
Bro I know you probably know this but mentzer also took meth then trained lmao.
Tone are your workouts quick and minimal set and exercises like Mike was teaching?
Similar but more like Dorian with 2-3 warm up sets 1 working set with maximum effort and 4-5 exercises with each body part being trained every 6 days. I do change up my workouts though and will incorporate drop sets and supersets and other advanced training techniques.
I believe the best way to stimulate muscle growth is to do both. Every workout gave a exercise where you do 1-2 Heavy-duty style training and other exercises where you focus on contractions and squeezing advanced hypermia style training filling up the muscle with nutrient rich blood.
I still keep my workouts to 60-90 min more like 90 on back and legs days
Ok sounds like you have mastered your craft. Good shit
After training almost a quarter century, overcoming injuries, complete tendon tears that could potentially take one out this game I've learned a thing or two. I've tried different things and found out what works. I thing basic exercises are still best and I see these youngsters doing all this wierd awkward looking shit or sitting sideways on a machine is not efficient and probably nit good for your bio mechanics. Stick to basics they work then they work now
Woke lifters hahaha
Lol like that
I love Dorian yates. I could listen to him talk and hear his views all day. Not just gym related stuff but about the wider world. I’ll book mark this and watch it later.
Yes a very interesting guy. Speaks DMT and Ayahuasca and spirituality if that’s your thing. Smart guy though.
I have a friend that’s visited a shaman multiple times under DMT…. His exact words were an instant connection to the spirit realm… mesmerizing experience.
Interesting or are you just tripping balls lol
Take the information for what’s it’s worth brother….. never fancied doing that shit myself
I’m not sure if I would try it but I find it quite interesting from stories I have heard. Maybe under a completely controlled environment with an expert.
Definitely. He was doing it the beach with these hippie types about 20- 40 of them and it was starting getting out of hand. He was considering a more controlled environment and ultra personal just you and the shaman. He did say if you’re going through any shit in life it will sort out your head out giving a new perspective on life…. not really my thing though
It’s fine to take bits and pieces of his teaching but for me the major problem with Mentzer and later Yates style training was that because the volume is so low, the intensity has to be at a level where injury risk begins to rise.
I would say Yates and Mentzer it up as a young man and once the injuries start to arise switch to a more sustainable model with less load and more longevity.
Yet still I believe he realized it (DY) a bit late he got a bicep tear in he's last Olympia which imo he did not deserve!!
Good point! I never looked at it from that standpoint.
Guy was one bad dude.... i heard he used meth preworkout and only trained like 3 days a week... idk wuts true other than he was on another level for sure.
I thought he abused stimulants because he was obsessed with studying and reading
Well thats what most people do these days when they walk around with a backpack full of crap...theyre not tweakin theyre studying on foot
His time under tension principles are not revolutionary but they are needed for growth. At least I don't think he invented forced negatives. rest/pause, slow eccentrics etc. Intensity of workouts is ok but not nearly enough volume/frequency for me to make it work. Also is pretty boring. I am more of a Poliquin type of guy. That is what works for me.
I love Mentzer. He knew physiology very well & was excellent at listening to his body & how it responded to stimuli. To make it to where he did while going against the grain of conventional thought is impressive. I have & do use some of his principals with great success. I firmly believe in the idea that intensity is a necessary component to the type of progress we’re all looking to achieve, no matter what training style we prefer. Also, I really like how he prioritized symmetric fullness. He had a great physique.
First thing ill say, i was a hardcore fan of those two.
BUT the conclusion i took after trying was: as long as stimulus and diet are on point, you grow with any method, theres no miracle workout. And if you are on gear it makes it easier.
Dorian Yates was Mr Olympia many times, inspired by Mentzer, but theres also a lot more multiple time Mr Olympia winners who didnt train that way. So to me, it proves nothing.
What I gathered from Mentzer is the correct movements and even more important the rest. It’s an interesting concept. I know one person who swears by it and he says he’s never seen as much growth and strength. I can’t co-sign that because I really don’t know since I don’t workout with him. I think mentally it’s difficult to stick to every 72hrs. I would feel like I’m cheating myself. I don’t think gear has anything to do with it because Yates was obviously on a ton of shit. I just wanted to put it out there to see other’s opinions that’s all. It’s a good conversation piece.
Its interesting indeed!