sawyteee's picture
sawyteee
  • 2
711

Not losing enough weight

ad

I very easily gain weight. For example if I don't track what I eat for a month I gain about 10 lbs during that time and this weight is very hard to lose. I workout every other day and am very active but my weight loss is about 0.5 lbs per week at best so it takes me a 2-3 months to lose the weight I gain in ONE month! I don't have any health issues. Is this normal? Any ideas why I'm losing it so slowly?

Danlaroy's picture

I think everyone gains weight faster. 0.5 pounds a week is good. It's still progress but to lose more I'd do more cardio or burn more calories instead of lowering what you're eating.

Kilroy's picture

This is normal for a lot of people. The idea that weight gained is a function only of calories in and calories out is wrong. When you're eating freely, your body passes a lot of calories through, or burns them up in ways that don't produce fat, e.g., via mitochondrial uncoupling. Your body has a certain weight it wants to be. When you go over that, it burns a higher fractions of the calories you eat away. When you go UNDER that weight, it grabs onto those calories hard, and tries to convert every gram of carbs into glucose or fat. So you can cut your caloric intake, and over a considerable range--from the point where your body is dumping calories to generate heat, down to the point where it's grabbing every gram and turning it into fat--you won't lose much weight.

There's also a variety of ways to metabolize the different macronutrients, which are more or less efficient, and direct calories to energy or to fat. You want your body to be less efficient. The point of the keto diet is to turn on less-efficient fat-burning pathways.

People vary in their % bodyfat set points, AND they vary in how active their hunger signalling system is. If you have a high setpoint and a low threshold for hunger, you're going to have a VERY HARD TIME losing weight. You CAN lose it by cutting calories enough, but it is MUCH more difficult for some people than for others. The guys who are at 7% bodyfat and say losing weight is just a matter of "getting a handle on your nutrition" are genetically gifted and have no understanding of what some people have to go thru to lose fat.

Try a keto diet, try reading "Nature wants you to be fat". Try drastically reducing fructose. Try low-intensity long-duration exercise. Eg, if you're gonna make a phone call or read your email, go out walking or do it on a treadmill. Exercise while watching TV.

Keep track of your hunger response. Try intermittent fasting. I find it's much easier to fast in the morning than in the evening, so skipping breakfast every day is good for me. Fasting for 2 days once each 2 weeks is easier than fasting 1 day once a week.

HanginLow's picture

people chronically under report what they eat, I have seen this a million times, I guarantee you are not eating 1200cals

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/1454084/

Working in the nutrition field in the past I can tell you that 3/4 the people that would come into our business would tell us they are "eating next to nothing" yet maintaining 300-500lbs of bodyweight.... that can only happen through eating enough calories to support that weight (upwards of 10000cals in some cases unknowingly)

You have to track everything that goes into your mouth, every sauce and condiment, every time you put butter on the pan to cook your chicken (common mistake), every oil, every soda, everything! And check to make sure what you scanned is accurate, yes it takes work.

When you do this you will see how much hidden calories you have been consuming.

Owes a Review × 1
TABMEISTER's picture

Why did you get on steroids if you don't even know how to properly lose weight. I'm not hating, but I find it a bit odd.

Makwa's picture

You should safely be able to lose about 1.5 - 2lbs/wk without sacrificing much muscle depending on where your BF % is at. Higher bodyfat will be easier to lose more weight. Cals in vs cals out for the most part. How large of a calorie deficit are doing when trying to lose weight?

sawyteee's picture

Thank you for the reply. Unfortunately I don't know my body fat %, but I don't think it's high. I eat under 1200 calories a day. Is this not enough and may be the reason I'm not losing as much as I could? Logically it shouldn't work that way and the less calories I consume, the more I should lose.

ThinSkin's picture

Interestingly enough I have had some similar metabolic issues and was only losing on 1500/day for a bit. I did a 5 day fast where I lost like 8lbs then followed by a refeed week at about 3500cal/day where I only gained 3lbs after that I switched to 2000 cal and losing 2lbs/week. So was able to lose more weight on more calories after a reset.

More conventional wisdom will indicate a once weekly cheat meal or once monthly refeed of a weekend or something or as needed when weight loss plateaus. Obviously the other problem ends up being the yoyoing and net zero, so have to watch your weight in the refeed times if longer than 1 meal and cap gains at 1/2 your losses or something.

Kilroy's picture

1200 calories a day is not enough, and you might have anorexia. An anorexic can look in the mirror at a body where the bones are literally visible through the skin, and just not see them. You WILL eventually die on 1200 calories a day unless you're a midget.

In any case, you should definitely try shaking that up somehow. You want to fake out your body until it stops hoarding fat. Try pigging out once a week, but not on high-glycemic-index sugars or grains. Try spreading your calories across 6 meals some weeks; try eating just 1 big meal a day sometimes.

Keep track of your macronutrient balance: grams of fat, protein, & sugars. Count sugar alcohols as sugar. Shift that macronutrient balance around each week.

ThinSkin's picture

Interestingly enough I have had some similar metabolic issues and was only losing on 1500/day for a bit. I did a 5 day fast where I lost like 8lbs then followed by a refeed week at about 3500cal/week where I only gained 3lbs after that I switched to 2000 cal and losing 2lbs/week. So was able to lose more weight on more calories after a reset.

More conventional wisdom will indicate a once weekly cheat meal or once monthly refeed of a weekend or something or as needed when weight loss plateaus. Obviously the other problem ends up being the yoyoing and net zero, so have to watch your weight in the refeed times if longer than 1 meal and cap gains at 1/2 your losses or something.

Makwa's picture

1200 cals/d is not healthy. Body is probably in starvation mode. You need to do a lot of research on dieting. Read through my forums on dieting. It is pretty easty to figure out what you are doing wrong.

More by sawyteee