gearreindeer666's picture
gearreindeer666
  • 20
1754

Are heart rate calorie calculators accurate?

ad

Hi all, was wondering how accurate these are

Danlaroy's picture

Not really and here's why, say you record a 20 minute cardio session at 150 bpm. It stops at the end of that 20 minutes obviously but does your heart immediately jump back to a resting rate? No, you're still burning a higher amount of calories. Another factor is how much you weigh. If you don't put in your weight most exercise machines default to 145 lbs which is less than most people weigh so you're burning more. If you are putting in your weight is that accurate? Weight fluctuates. They do give you a good ballpark to track progress though.

Dare_devil's picture

Do I understand correctly that in reality you burn more than the calculator thinks? What do you think is the error?
But I agreed it's a great guideline.

Dare_devil's picture

This is a very proven and effective tool. When the exact numbers are in front of your eyes, you can manage the number of calories, it is very convenient.

Dare_devil's picture

I have my trainer, he told me that he actively uses them and there have always been no problems with the accuracy of the readings.

HanginLow's picture

Yes but make sure you are using chronometer or a custom food tracker app because I see the most mistakes with those with cals in and out .

Owes a Review × 1
Makwa's picture

Pretty dang accurate. I don’t know how I was ever able to cut or do a prep without one. Much easier know

Diesel77's picture

Most of the HR based calculations are within 10-20% accurate. That's not as close as within 5% with power, but not everyone wants to or can invest in that technology....per Google

Dare_devil's picture

And where does the information about the error of 10-20% come from, this is a lot, it seems like nutrition experts say that it is quite accurate.

Diesel77's picture

Google....are heart rate calorie calculators accurate?

Dare_devil's picture

It’s just that the reviews of athletes and trainers indicate that they are quite accurate.

Diesel77's picture

You asked where it came from, I answered.