+ 2 (Study) Increased Volume Leads to Increased Hypertrophy Between Groups, But with No Strength again Differences
Came across this on NIH and thought it was interesting/pretty surprising.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/30153194/
One sentence summary: After an 8 week training period, 3 groups with different training volumes had hypertrophy increases based on their level of volume, but had no major strength changes between them comparatively.
Summary:
34 participants were split in to 3 groups.
11 in low volume (1 set per exercise per training session)
12 in medium volume (3 sets)
11 in high volume (5 sets)
They trained 3 days a week on non consecutive days for 8 weeks. At the end of the study, they were tested on their 1RM for strength and max reps at 50% of their 1RM for endurance, as well as their muscle mass in the arms and quad areas.
As expected, the high volume group gained more muscle mass, and all groups gained a significant amount of strength, but there were NO (statistically) significant differences between the groups in their strength levels.
Criticisms:
They don’t go into details on how much the weight varied between the groups. Seeing as most powerlifter programs are low rep but high weights, this makes sense... but we don’t know what kind of exercises or weights they used in this.
They don’t discuss what the actual changes were, or any real background on the participants.
They don’t discuss recovery requirements/soreness/nutrition.
We’re the strength gains relative to the individual? Or overall?
What else do y’all think about this? Have any of you guys ever experienced anything like this/tried something similar in your training?
- Bookmark
- 2
- 0
RustyhookerI get larger with volume. If i want strength my training is very different. For me its pick one or the other and switch every few weeks to keep it fun.
basskiller89Hey brother,
I always use ncbi when possible, sometimes it's a bit hard to decipher the studies. This is what works for me from personal expreince. The best hypertrophy gains I ever had were from 3-4 sets of 8-12 reps per exercise keeping workouts around 40-60 minutes, sometimes only 30 minutes. At the end of 8 weeks I noticed that my 1 rep max was significantly higher without training in the 3-5 rep range. The most size I have ever put on was on the same routine. Keep in mind I was on cycle for both. I think that the same principles of strength on cycle exist off cycle in the appropriate margins. Size is a different story. I enjoy training 5 days a week and have definitely taken 1-2 weeks off just to reset with no hiccups. Strength in itself is an electric impulse sent from the brain. Electromagnetic currencies allow the muscle to contract with either a focus on type 1 twitches or type 2 twitches. The more force you train with the stronger you will be. For example, if two participants in a trial are benching 185 for 8 reps: whoever applies the most force and speed to the rep will have more type 2 muscle fibers, which results in a stronger lift, assuming the mental and physical aspects are in place. Now take the same participant with more force on 185lbs for 8 reps on bench press and compare them to a participant with a slow controlled 185lb bench press for 8 reps. The participant with slow and controlled speeds will develop type 1 muscle fibers which will result in endurance. The type 1 fibers will have a smoother more controlled set where as the individual with type 2 fibers will have a higher force output to start and a lower force output to finish. The analogy I can give is linebackers in the NFl primary have type 1 muscle twitch fibers. A running back is going to have primarily type 2 muscle twitch fibers. It depends what you are looking for and what you are looking for within a strength range. Type 1 muscle twitch fibers may allow you to bench 225 for 1 and 185 for 8 reps where as type 2 muscle twitch fibers may allow for a max of 200lbs and 185lbs for 12 reps. Holding 185lbs for 20 seconds is a lot different than holding 185lbs for 10 seconds
This is all pretty obvious stuff already I'd of thought - Of course someone doing high volume isn't going to be stronger in a 1RM than someone training with less sets and therefore much less fatigue and soreness. Hence if you want to increase a 1RM that's what you train and why most PLing cycles start with more volume and reps and peak down to much less volume and singles/doubles.
That’s part of the flaws with this study though (or at least the summary of it).
We don’t know if these were power lifters vs body builders/body building style lifters, or if they were all regular joes that participated from the same baseline.
The point the study seems like it’s trying to make is:
We had 34 people in three groups. All the exact same size and lifting experience. They all had the same Back squat 1RM. All three groups did the same exercises and reps per set, but the groups did different amounts of sets. Each group gained muscle, but the 5 set group put in the most muscle. However all of their 1RM maxes increased to 245 regardless of how much muscle or how many sets.
But again, they give next to no background info on the participants so everything i just said is hypothetical
Look into blood flow restriction (BFR) training. 20% of 1RM doing sets 30/15/15/15. The kicker is you place a tourniquet on either the most proximal portion arms or legs depending on what you are training. Now you have to be careful when utilizing this because the tourniquet is not meant to completely cut off blood flow as it is intended be used. Instead it should be wrapped tightly enough to occluded venous return but not arterial flow into the muscle. So blood is allowed to flow into the muscle but not out of it. This cause a metabolic build up that causes the slow twitch fibers to become fatigued and the fast twitch fibers to take over at such a load. The metabolic stress is thought to activate the mTOR pathway and hormonal response and massive release GH (290 times https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/dc83/952143b19d7256151f55e25f67ad667e87...)
I've been using it as a "finisher" set at the end of heavy workouts for one body part (curls, calve raises, leg ext/curl). It can also be used as a form of periodization, train heavy 3 weeks then all BFR workouts for the last week. Been seeing more and more pros using it their training. If you want an insane pump, give it a try! But like I said you need to look into the protocol a little more if you plan on using it, pneumatic cuffs cost about $5,000 so outta the question for most lifters. You can use knee wraps, or I bought my from https://www.bfrshop.com/ and think they work very well. When using the elastic wraps they should be about a 7/10 on a pain scale.
The researchers’ definitions of low, medium, and high volumes are really bizarre. Worthless study across the board. No use to athletes in practice; no use to scientists in academia. Wasted grant.
Another flawed study! There are so many out there!
I was thinking that when trying to read all this. I thought what is the purpose of this study? The scientists observed some bodybuilders and said hey I have an idea for a new study to get some grant money.. Imo, If u lift weight, there will be some form of hypertrophy and strength gain (even minimum). Same as, will an active person live longer than a non-active person. Ofcoarse I'm no scientist but I did stay in a Motel 6 last night!. Common sense says yes but to conduct an experiment wld take years to prove... lol
Key word is statistically no changes in strength. So they didnt test it statistically. Meaning further testing is warranted.
Like you mentioned in your criticism of the study, there are way to many details missing to make this of any real use or to draw inferences from it.
I think 8 weeks isnt near long enough to guage anything.
8 months would be more realistic.